Defining the "proven technology" technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program

Nuraslinda Anuar, Wan Shakirah Wan Abdul Kahar, Jamal Abdul Nasir Abd Manan

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Developing countries that are considering the deployment of nuclear power plants (NPPs) in the near future need to perform reactor technology assessment (RTA) in order to select the most suitable reactor design. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reported in the Common User Considerations (CUC) document that "proven technology" is one of the most important technical criteria for newcomer countries in performing the RTA. The qualitative description of five desired features for "proven technology" is relatively broad and only provides a general guideline to its characterization. This paper proposes a methodology to define the "proven technology" term according to a specific country's requirements using a three-stage evaluation process. The first evaluation stage screens the available technologies in the market against a predefined minimum Technology Readiness Level (TRL) derived as a condition based on national needs and policy objectives. The result is a list of technology options, which are then assessed in the second evaluation stage against quantitative definitions of CUC desired features for proven technology. The potential technology candidates produced from this evaluation is further narrowed down to obtain a list of proven technology candidates by assessing them against selected risk criteria and the established maximum allowable total score using a scoring matrix. The outcome of this methodology is the proven technology candidates selected using an accurate definition of "proven technology" that fulfills the policy objectives, national needs and risk, and country-specific CUC desired features of the country that performs this assessment. A simplified assessment for Malaysia is carried out to demonstrate and suggest the use of the proposed methodology. In this exercise, ABWR, AP1000, APR1400 and EPR designs assumed the top-ranks of proven technology candidates according to Malaysia's definition of "proven technology".

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationAdvancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development
Subtitle of host publicationProceedings of the Nuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014, NuSTEC 2014
EditorsKhaidzir Hamzah, Faridah Mohamad Idris, Abu Bakar Hasan, Abdul Aziz Mohamed
PublisherAmerican Institute of Physics Inc.
ISBN (Electronic)9780735413016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 29 Apr 2015
EventNuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014: Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development, NuSTEC 2014 - Skudai, Johor, Malaysia
Duration: 11 Nov 201413 Nov 2014

Publication series

NameAIP Conference Proceedings
Volume1659
ISSN (Print)0094-243X
ISSN (Electronic)1551-7616

Other

OtherNuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014: Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development, NuSTEC 2014
CountryMalaysia
CitySkudai, Johor
Period11/11/1413/11/14

Fingerprint

technology assessment
reactor technology
Malaysia
evaluation
methodology
lists
reactor design
scoring
nuclear power plants
physical exercise
nuclear energy
requirements
matrices

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Ecology
  • Plant Science
  • Physics and Astronomy(all)
  • Nature and Landscape Conservation

Cite this

Anuar, N., Kahar, W. S. W. A., & Manan, J. A. N. A. (2015). Defining the "proven technology" technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program. In K. Hamzah, F. M. Idris, A. B. Hasan, & A. A. Mohamed (Eds.), Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development: Proceedings of the Nuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014, NuSTEC 2014 [020006] (AIP Conference Proceedings; Vol. 1659). American Institute of Physics Inc.. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4916845
Anuar, Nuraslinda ; Kahar, Wan Shakirah Wan Abdul ; Manan, Jamal Abdul Nasir Abd. / Defining the "proven technology" technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program. Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development: Proceedings of the Nuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014, NuSTEC 2014. editor / Khaidzir Hamzah ; Faridah Mohamad Idris ; Abu Bakar Hasan ; Abdul Aziz Mohamed. American Institute of Physics Inc., 2015. (AIP Conference Proceedings).
@inproceedings{3c099b84a74945be8ed596cd25ff8bd0,
title = "Defining the {"}proven technology{"} technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program",
abstract = "Developing countries that are considering the deployment of nuclear power plants (NPPs) in the near future need to perform reactor technology assessment (RTA) in order to select the most suitable reactor design. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reported in the Common User Considerations (CUC) document that {"}proven technology{"} is one of the most important technical criteria for newcomer countries in performing the RTA. The qualitative description of five desired features for {"}proven technology{"} is relatively broad and only provides a general guideline to its characterization. This paper proposes a methodology to define the {"}proven technology{"} term according to a specific country's requirements using a three-stage evaluation process. The first evaluation stage screens the available technologies in the market against a predefined minimum Technology Readiness Level (TRL) derived as a condition based on national needs and policy objectives. The result is a list of technology options, which are then assessed in the second evaluation stage against quantitative definitions of CUC desired features for proven technology. The potential technology candidates produced from this evaluation is further narrowed down to obtain a list of proven technology candidates by assessing them against selected risk criteria and the established maximum allowable total score using a scoring matrix. The outcome of this methodology is the proven technology candidates selected using an accurate definition of {"}proven technology{"} that fulfills the policy objectives, national needs and risk, and country-specific CUC desired features of the country that performs this assessment. A simplified assessment for Malaysia is carried out to demonstrate and suggest the use of the proposed methodology. In this exercise, ABWR, AP1000, APR1400 and EPR designs assumed the top-ranks of proven technology candidates according to Malaysia's definition of {"}proven technology{"}.",
author = "Nuraslinda Anuar and Kahar, {Wan Shakirah Wan Abdul} and Manan, {Jamal Abdul Nasir Abd}",
year = "2015",
month = "4",
day = "29",
doi = "10.1063/1.4916845",
language = "English",
series = "AIP Conference Proceedings",
publisher = "American Institute of Physics Inc.",
editor = "Khaidzir Hamzah and Idris, {Faridah Mohamad} and Hasan, {Abu Bakar} and Mohamed, {Abdul Aziz}",
booktitle = "Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development",

}

Anuar, N, Kahar, WSWA & Manan, JANA 2015, Defining the "proven technology" technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program. in K Hamzah, FM Idris, AB Hasan & AA Mohamed (eds), Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development: Proceedings of the Nuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014, NuSTEC 2014., 020006, AIP Conference Proceedings, vol. 1659, American Institute of Physics Inc., Nuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014: Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development, NuSTEC 2014, Skudai, Johor, Malaysia, 11/11/14. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4916845

Defining the "proven technology" technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program. / Anuar, Nuraslinda; Kahar, Wan Shakirah Wan Abdul; Manan, Jamal Abdul Nasir Abd.

Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development: Proceedings of the Nuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014, NuSTEC 2014. ed. / Khaidzir Hamzah; Faridah Mohamad Idris; Abu Bakar Hasan; Abdul Aziz Mohamed. American Institute of Physics Inc., 2015. 020006 (AIP Conference Proceedings; Vol. 1659).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Defining the "proven technology" technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program

AU - Anuar, Nuraslinda

AU - Kahar, Wan Shakirah Wan Abdul

AU - Manan, Jamal Abdul Nasir Abd

PY - 2015/4/29

Y1 - 2015/4/29

N2 - Developing countries that are considering the deployment of nuclear power plants (NPPs) in the near future need to perform reactor technology assessment (RTA) in order to select the most suitable reactor design. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reported in the Common User Considerations (CUC) document that "proven technology" is one of the most important technical criteria for newcomer countries in performing the RTA. The qualitative description of five desired features for "proven technology" is relatively broad and only provides a general guideline to its characterization. This paper proposes a methodology to define the "proven technology" term according to a specific country's requirements using a three-stage evaluation process. The first evaluation stage screens the available technologies in the market against a predefined minimum Technology Readiness Level (TRL) derived as a condition based on national needs and policy objectives. The result is a list of technology options, which are then assessed in the second evaluation stage against quantitative definitions of CUC desired features for proven technology. The potential technology candidates produced from this evaluation is further narrowed down to obtain a list of proven technology candidates by assessing them against selected risk criteria and the established maximum allowable total score using a scoring matrix. The outcome of this methodology is the proven technology candidates selected using an accurate definition of "proven technology" that fulfills the policy objectives, national needs and risk, and country-specific CUC desired features of the country that performs this assessment. A simplified assessment for Malaysia is carried out to demonstrate and suggest the use of the proposed methodology. In this exercise, ABWR, AP1000, APR1400 and EPR designs assumed the top-ranks of proven technology candidates according to Malaysia's definition of "proven technology".

AB - Developing countries that are considering the deployment of nuclear power plants (NPPs) in the near future need to perform reactor technology assessment (RTA) in order to select the most suitable reactor design. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reported in the Common User Considerations (CUC) document that "proven technology" is one of the most important technical criteria for newcomer countries in performing the RTA. The qualitative description of five desired features for "proven technology" is relatively broad and only provides a general guideline to its characterization. This paper proposes a methodology to define the "proven technology" term according to a specific country's requirements using a three-stage evaluation process. The first evaluation stage screens the available technologies in the market against a predefined minimum Technology Readiness Level (TRL) derived as a condition based on national needs and policy objectives. The result is a list of technology options, which are then assessed in the second evaluation stage against quantitative definitions of CUC desired features for proven technology. The potential technology candidates produced from this evaluation is further narrowed down to obtain a list of proven technology candidates by assessing them against selected risk criteria and the established maximum allowable total score using a scoring matrix. The outcome of this methodology is the proven technology candidates selected using an accurate definition of "proven technology" that fulfills the policy objectives, national needs and risk, and country-specific CUC desired features of the country that performs this assessment. A simplified assessment for Malaysia is carried out to demonstrate and suggest the use of the proposed methodology. In this exercise, ABWR, AP1000, APR1400 and EPR designs assumed the top-ranks of proven technology candidates according to Malaysia's definition of "proven technology".

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84997078945&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84997078945&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1063/1.4916845

DO - 10.1063/1.4916845

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:84997078945

T3 - AIP Conference Proceedings

BT - Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development

A2 - Hamzah, Khaidzir

A2 - Idris, Faridah Mohamad

A2 - Hasan, Abu Bakar

A2 - Mohamed, Abdul Aziz

PB - American Institute of Physics Inc.

ER -

Anuar N, Kahar WSWA, Manan JANA. Defining the "proven technology" technical criterion in the reactor technology assessment for Malaysia's nuclear power program. In Hamzah K, Idris FM, Hasan AB, Mohamed AA, editors, Advancing of Nuclear Science and Energy for National Development: Proceedings of the Nuclear Science, Technology, and Engineering Conference 2014, NuSTEC 2014. American Institute of Physics Inc. 2015. 020006. (AIP Conference Proceedings). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4916845